BeyondCorn: The real raw material for the biofuel revolution

22

The real cost of #biofuels: Why corn ethanol is comparable to oil

Biofuels are still the holy grail of energy research, but we haven’t yet cracked the code to completely replace oil. Math doesn’t lie. We can’t just look at oil prices and stop there. Energy density varies greatly depending on the type of fuel. Comparing prices per gallon is misleading. To find out the truth, we need to look at the price per unit of energy.

The data at the end of 2010 were gloomy. Gasoline costs an average of about $2.78 per unit of energy. ethanol? The same result costs about $3.45. Clean energy competition is too expensive. Biodiesel fares slightly better at around $2.86. It is close, but still more expensive than conventional crude oil.

The promise is there. Fuel is getting cheaper. The sky is now clear. The reality is more disturbing. Inexpensive biofuels often come with hidden environmental responsibilities. Land use change. water stress. “Next generation” materials such as algae and grass have potential, but are still too expensive to produce at scale.

What do we have today? Here are five options you can take to prevent your house from falling down. Let’s start with the bigger one.

5. Maize

Corn is the undisputed king of biofuel production in the United States. It is very cheap. It is very rich. But it’s not exactly a green miracle. There is a problem with the energy balance. We invest a lot of fossil energy in growing, harvesting and processing corn. The return on invested capital is modest.

Corn is the star of the conversation, but it’s not the only thing on the table. As of 2010, 187 plants produced ethanol in the United States, most of which used corn as the primary feedstock. This advantage has its pros and cons. On the other hand, corn ethanol reduces greenhouse gas emissions compared to fossil fuels. On the other hand, the energy per gallon is lower. When you switch to this biofuel, you will notice that your mileage will drop significantly. In addition, food security are also urgent. Expanding corn ethanol production can cause significant food shortages.

Critics also point out the hypocrisy of the environment. When grasslands and rainforests are cleared to grow corn, the carbon debt caused by deforestation is often greater than the benefit from burning the fuel. The processing itself is energy intensive and highly dependent on fossil fuels. Despite these shortcomings, the industry bets big on the crop. Currently, about a third of the corn grown in the United States is used for fuel instead of food.

How Brazil dominated sugarcane ethanol

Sugarcane tells a different story, starting with Brazil. This success is no accident. It started decades ago, triggered by the 1973 Middle East oil embargo and the subsequent rise in fuel prices. The Brazilian government also intervened and provided significant support. They mandated that the big oil companies blend ethanol into their fuels. They provided $4.9 billion in low-interest loans to encourage private investment. Initially, fuel subsidies were granted so that consumers could buy cheaper.

Today, these subsidies are a thing of the past. The market has adapted. More than 70% of new cars sold in Brazil are “flex-fuel” vehicles. These machines can run on several different fuels, from pure ethanol to mixtures containing only 25% ethanol. The rest is gasoline.

Why can’t everyone do this? Climate is the biggest obstacle. Countries like the United States lack the unique weather patterns needed to grow sugarcane on a large scale. Brazil has the perfect combination of heat, rain and available land. This was a geographic lottery win that made sugarcane a viable large-scale fuel source domestically, but largely unreachable in temperate regions.

Vegetable oil and biodiesel discussion

Next is the world of vegetable oils. The main products here are rapeseed, palm oil and soy. They are used to make biodiesel, a renewable fuel that differs from ethanol. The performance numbers are nuanced. Biodiesel’s fuel economy is better than regular gasoline, but still lower than petroleum-based diesel. Pure biodiesel has about 10% lower fuel consumption and power than regular diesel. Blends with petrodiesel perform better than pure petrodiesel, but are about 2% less efficient.

Canola is a common food ingredient in the United States and Canada. A member of the mustard family, this plant produces seeds that are surprisingly oily, containing about 40% oil by weight. Palm oil, which is harvested in massive quantities in Malaysia and Indonesia, looks economically attractive. However, it has created a serious environmental stigma.

These criticisms mirror those of corn ethanol. The use of these plants replaced food production. Clearing natural areas to plant palm trees and soybeans increases the net amount of greenhouse gas emissions. Clearing the land, planting fuel crops and burning the crop is still controversial.

Initiatives to recycle cooking oil

The final piece of this feedstock puzzle is perhaps the circular. Recycled cooking fats and oils offer a route that doesn’t require new land.

Fat can Reality

It sounds gross, but waste materials like used cooking oil and grease are actually cheap and attractive materials. Environmentally friendly and affordable. Problems such as land use, energy consumption and environmental impact, which are often encountered with cultivated materials such as corn, sugar cane and palm trees, can be solved by using already existing materials that should be disposed of anyway. “Yellow grease” is the term for recycled cooking oil, including soybean oil, palm oil, canola oil, etc., and is a waste product used as fuel. Of course, you can’t just pour used restaurant grease into your car’s gas tank. First, it must be processed to remove impurities and convert it into a clean burning fuel.

Jatropha: The much touted hope

The seeds of the noxious weed shrub Jatropha curcas have received considerable attention as a potential raw material, especially in India and Africa. Jatropha is not edible, so its use as a fuel does not conflict with its use as a food plant. This is a common problem with many biofuel sources. Jatropha plants have excellent tolerance to cold, drought and fast growth. The seeds contain up to 40% oil, which makes them of particular interest to researchers looking for cheap raw materials. All of these features seem promising, but so far Jatropha plants do not seem to be producing adequate yields. Probably because it is grown in “marginal” soils that are not of sufficient quality. Jatropha also requires a lot of water to grow. Therefore, although this factory is cheap, it may not be suitable for mass production.

Why can waste oil win in logistics?

The real advantage of use oil waste biofuel is the simplicity of the supply chain. You don’t need acres of farmland. There is no need to negotiate the price of the crop with the farmers. The ingredients are already there, at the bottom of the restaurant’s grease trap. The biggest obstacle is not growing it, but collecting it.

Yellow grease refers to recycled oil from deep fryers. Soybeans, palm and canola are also acceptable. The key is waste. Used cooking oil requires a different processing route than virgin vegetable oil. Must be filtered. Impurities must be removed. Next, the transesterification reaction takes place. This chemical process turns the fat into biodiesel. The result is clean burning fuel.

Compare this with Jatropha. This bush sounds good on paper. It also grows in poor soil. It is poisonous and cannot be eaten by humans. The seeds contain about 40% oil. However, the yield is low. Soil quality is more important than advertised. The need for water is very high. Marginal lands often lack nutrients to support continuous growth. Many of these areas are in water bodies. According to the calculations, it is not mass produced.

Waste cooking oil biodiesel avoids these agricultural variables. Input is standard. The result is predictable. The technology exists. The infrastructure is catching up.

Energy balance discussion

Proponents of plant-based fuels often cite the return on energy investment. This affects Jatropha biodiesel. The energy needed to grow, maintain and harvest the bushes can approach the energy contained in the final fuel. **W